On September 2, 2026, a house at 1360 Lorain sold for $4,290,000. It has 3,342 square feet, a 10,111-square-foot lot and a 2021 build date. Ten weeks later, on November 13, a house at 2500 Monterey closed at $3,134,310. That house has 3,450 square feet, sits on a 10,073-square-foot lot and was built in 1925. The lots differ by 38 square feet and the houses by about a hundred. The sale prices are roughly $1.16 million apart, and that gap is about what a five-year-old house was worth over a hundred-year-old one on the same amount of San Marino land this fall.
The pair is unusual because the land is held equal. In most San Marino sales it isn't, and once land is allowed to vary, it explains more of the price than anything else on the listing sheet.
Eight sales from June to November, sorted by land
Here are eight closed San Marino sales from June through mid-November 2026, sorted from the largest lot to the smallest.
| Address | Sale date | Lot size | House size | Year built | Sale price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1230 Winston Ave | Nov 13, 2026 | 24,847 sq ft | 4,022 sq ft | 1941 | $4,560,000 |
| 1640 Bedford | Jul 6, 2026 | 24,772 sq ft | 2,769 sq ft | 1954 | $3,550,000 |
| 5 Kewen Place | Jun 9, 2026 | 20,079 sq ft | 3,024 sq ft | 1953 | $3,451,000 |
| 2932 Gainsborough Dr | Sep 16, 2026 | 12,746 sq ft | 4,365 sq ft | 1941 | $3,450,000 |
| 1360 Lorain | Sep 2, 2026 | 10,111 sq ft | 3,342 sq ft | 2021 | $4,290,000 |
| 2500 Monterey | Nov 13, 2026 | 10,073 sq ft | 3,450 sq ft | 1925 | $3,134,310 |
| 1659 S Oak Knoll Ave | Nov 12, 2026 | 6,488 sq ft | 1,992 sq ft | 1927 | $2,380,000 |
| 1735 Hilliard Dr | Oct 8, 2026 | 6,411 sq ft | 1,863 sq ft | 1973 | $1,950,000 |
Read down the lot column and the price column follows it closely. Every sale on more than 12,000 square feet of land closed at $3.45 million or higher. Both sales on lots under 6,500 square feet closed below $2.4 million. Lorain is the one sale that jumps out of order, and it's also the one new house in the group.
Now try the measure most buyers bring from other cities, price per square foot of house. Over the same eight sales it runs from about $790 at Gainsborough Drive to about $1,284 at Lorain. That spread is wide enough to make the number close to useless for comparing two San Marino homes. Gainsborough has the biggest house on the table and the lowest price per square foot. Bedford has one of the smaller houses and nearly the highest. Divide each price by its lot instead, and the order makes more sense.
Why the lots are where they are
San Marino's lot sizes aren't random, and most of them were set before anyone now living in these houses was born. The city's 2020 Citywide Historic Resources Survey traces the street pattern to the Pacific Electric lines Henry Huntington built between 1903 and 1906. Most of the grid runs at right angles to Huntington Drive, the northeast grid follows the Sierra Madre line, and the hilly northwest has curving streets and the largest lots.
The tracts laid down over the next fifty years produced very different parcels:
- Oak Knoll Marino, Tract 6012, was subdivided in 1923 by the Huntington Land & Improvement Company. It is bounded by Huntington Drive, Virginia Road, the Lacy Park open space and Oak Knoll Avenue, with wide curving streets and large lots. Across 1920s San Marino, lots grew larger with elevation to the north.
- Gainsborough Heath covered 297 acres and was advertised from 1927 with a plan for 1,000 houses. About 70 had been built by the end of World War II.
- San Marino–Patton Estates started in 1929 as about 50 acres of the Patton estate cut into 90 large lots between Huntington Drive, San Marino Avenue, Euston Road and Virginia Road. The Huntington Land & Improvement Company later re-divided it into smaller lots, and most of the building happened in the 1940s and 1950s.
- San Marino Highlands and San Marino Oaks, south of Huntington Drive in the eastern part of the city, were built by California Subdividers from the late 1930s into the early 1950s. They are mostly one-story Colonial Ranch, Cape Cod Ranch and Minimal Traditional houses, and the early Highlands houses averaged 1,600 square feet.
- Lake Vineyard Patton Estates, laid out in the early 1970s, added two cul-de-sacs and lots along Euston Road, including Patton Way.
Every one of those decisions fixed a parcel size that a later owner can't easily change. A house can be remodeled, expanded or replaced, as Lorain's 2021 build date shows. The lot under it stays the size a subdivider drew.
Huntington Drive doesn't divide the market
In these eight sales, which side of Huntington Drive a house sits on did less to set its price than the size of its lot. 1640 Bedford is south of Huntington Drive and west of San Marino Avenue. It's a 1954 house on 24,772 square feet, a little over half an acre, and it sold for $3,550,000 in July. Its listing gave 2,769 square feet, a figure that includes a detached bonus space of roughly 400 square feet next to a main house of about 2,369. That's a house close in size to an original Highlands ranch, and it sold for well over a million dollars more than the 1927 house at 1659 South Oak Knoll Avenue, a north San Marino address with 1,992 square feet on a 6,488-square-foot lot that closed at $2,380,000 in November.
The two least expensive sales in the group sit on opposite sides of Huntington Drive. 1735 Hilliard Drive is south of it, a 1973 house on 6,411 square feet that sold for $1,950,000 in October. The Oak Knoll Avenue house is north of it. What the two share is a lot of roughly 6,400 to 6,500 square feet.
5 Kewen Place shows the same pattern from the other direction. A 1953 house of 3,024 square feet on a 20,079-square-foot lot, it sold for $3,451,000 in June. A midcentury house on close to half an acre landed in the same price band as Gainsborough Drive's much larger 1941 house on a smaller lot.
Where the house does move the price
Land doesn't explain everything, and the exceptions are useful. Lorain is the clearest one. On a lot no bigger than Monterey's, a 2021 house brought about $1.16 million more than a 1925 house of nearly the same size. When the lot is held equal, a new house carries a large premium, and that premium is what makes rebuilding on an older parcel worth doing.
2932 Gainsborough Drive is the opposite case. The 1941 house has 4,365 square feet, the most of any sale here, on a 12,746-square-foot lot, and it sold for $3,450,000 in September. That's essentially the same price as Kewen Place, which has about 1,300 fewer square feet of house and about 7,300 more square feet of land. In this set of sales, a large older house didn't add as much value as a large lot did.
1230 Winston Avenue had both. A 1941 house with 4,022 square feet on 24,847 square feet of land sold for $4,560,000 on November 13, the highest price in the group.
Architecture still matters to the people who buy here. The survey records 1920s San Marino as mostly Period Revival, with Tudor Revival, Mediterranean Revival and Spanish Colonial Revival houses. It names Wallace Neff on Berkeley Street, Harold J. Bissner on Fleur Drive and Neff's own 1928 home at 1883 Orlando Road. Postwar infill in the north Oak Knoll area brought architect-designed Mid-Century Modern work, including a 1975 Buff & Hensman house at 1665 Euston Road. A known architect's name can set one sale apart from another. Across the general market, though, the eight closings from June through November line up by lot first and by house second.
Comparing San Marino listings lot first
For a buyer comparing San Marino homes this winter, this changes how two listings should be weighed against each other. Start with the lot size, then the age of the house, then the address. Two houses at the same price on lots 10,000 square feet apart are different purchases. In the 2026 sales above, one buyer is paying mostly for the land and the other mostly for the house, and a house can be remodeled or replaced while the lot stays the size it was drawn.
It also helps to read a listing against the tract it belongs to. The early Highlands houses were one-story ranches that averaged about 1,600 square feet, and the survey describes the 1920s parcels on the curving northwest streets as spacious from the start. The survey's maps of those tracts work as a guide to where large lots are common and where they're rare, which is why a half-acre parcel like Bedford's can bring a strong price on the south side.
Sellers can use the same order. A San Marino home with an older house on a generous lot is being judged mainly on the land, and its marketing should lead with the parcel. Our earlier piece on strategic pricing for San Marino luxury homes covers how list price and buyer expectations interact, and the San Marino neighborhood page has more on the city's streets and parks.
A few quick questions
Is price per square foot ever useful in San Marino? It's most useful when the lots being compared are close in size, as Lorain and Monterey were in September and November. Across lots of very different sizes, it ranged from about $790 to about $1,284 in these eight sales.
Do the 1920s tracts always mean bigger lots? The survey says lots in the 1920s subdivisions were spacious and grew larger with elevation to the north, and that the northwest has the city's largest lots. Individual parcels vary, and later re-divisions such as the one in Patton Estates produced smaller lots inside originally large tracts.
Where can I see current San Marino listings? Current inventory is on our San Marino homes for sale page. Buyers financing above conventional limits may also want to read our guide to jumbo loans in San Marino.
If you own a San Marino home and want to know what your lot, more than your square footage, is worth in today's market, Tony Dowdy can talk through how your parcel compares with this year's sales. Start with a free home valuation.